A chemical flame retardant commonly used in foam
furniture padding is accumulating so rapidly in the breast milk
of nursing mothers that environmentalists and some scientists
are calling for a ban on it.
Little is known about the toxic nature of polybrominated
diphenyl ether, commonly known by the acronym PBDE. Early studies
show it poses some of the same dangers as PCBs and DDT. Those
two chemicals were banned in the United States decades ago for
their myriad detrimental effects on animal and human health.
Environmentalists advocate a ban on PBDE as well.
One form of the chemical will be banned next year in Europe,
where the law requires proof of safety before a new agent can
be used in the environment. U.S. law requires proof of harm
or risk before a chemical is banned.
But the chemical industry argues that more research
is needed before banning something that protects lives. Producers
of PBDE say there is no evidence that it will ever reach harmful
levels, while its benefits as a flame retardant are well-known.
Adding PBDE to foam furniture padding, television
casings and other plastics reduces by 45 percent the risk of
death and injury due to fire, the chemical manufacturers say.
"We're not talking about aesthetics. People
use brominated flame retardants because they save lives,"
said Robert Campbell, a spokesman for Great Lakes Chemical Corp.
in West Lafayette, Ind.
Like PCBs and DDT, PBDE is a persistent organic
pollutant, or POP. POPs can remain in the environment for years
without breaking down. Some of these pollutants have such an
affinity for fat that they build up in the bodies of both animals
and humans from before birth until death.
"It seems that PBDEs are an important -
but generally unrecognized - persistent organic pollutant in
the United States," Robert C. Hale, a professor at the
Virginia Institute of Marine Sciences, and five colleagues wrote
in the journal Nature a few months ago.
Persistent organic pollutants are so difficult
to purge from the environment that 25 years after being banned,
trace amounts of PCBs can still be measured in human blood.
Waterways such as New York's Hudson River and Wisconsin's Fox
River are being dredged at costs running into the hundreds of
millions to rid them of PCB contamination. In many waters, anglers
are warned not to eat the fish they catch or to limit their
consumption to one or two servings a month.
"There is an enormous need to act quickly
when there is a problem with a chemical that is not only toxic
but is persistent and accumulates, because it will continue
to get worse before it gets better," said physician Gina
Solomon, a senior scientist at the Natural Resources Defense
Council.
Industry uses several forms of PBDE to decrease
the flammability of various plastics. Only one of those types
- used mostly in polyurethane foam furniture padding - has been
found in the environment and breast milk. According to Environmental
Protection Agency records, Great Lakes Chemical is the only
U.S. manufacturer of that form of PBDE.
"At this point all bets are open in terms
of how it's getting into the environment," said Hale, who
stops short of calling for a ban on the pollutant, which was
developed in the 1960s.
He has hypothesized that discarded furniture
is a major source of PBDE in the environment. Whenever anybody
tosses out an old sofa, he explained, nature goes to work. Water
and sunlight break the foam into crumbling pieces that eventually
are ground to dust. Insects have also been observed munching
away at the material. From those humble beginnings the chemical
travels all the way up the food chain to humans.
Hale has found PBDEs virtually everywhere he
has looked: In a small river along the North Carolina-Virginia
border, he found fish with the highest levels of PBDE ever recorded
in an animal. He has also collected sewage sludge samples from
four states, all with high concentrations of PBDE.
Swedish scientists first documented the increase
of PBDE in humans. For 30 years, Sweden has sampled the breast
milk of nursing mothers to track exposure to dioxin, PCBs and
other pollutants that accumulate in body fat. The United States
has no similar program.